It's 9:40 on a Friday night and you have been scrolling for forty minutes. You have a streaming service with thousands of titles, a partner on the couch, and a free evening. You open a show, watch four minutes of it, and back out because something better might be one row down. At 10:20 you put on a rerun you've seen six times. Nobody chose it. It was what remained when the search wore you out.
That evening is a small, ordinary version of a problem psychologists have studied for decades. We are told that freedom means options, and that more options mean more freedom. But somewhere past a certain point, options stop feeling like freedom. They start to feel like homework.
The famous jam study (and what it actually showed)
Most people who know this idea know it through a jar of jam. In a 2000 study, Sheena Iyengar and Mark Lepper set up tasting tables in a grocery store. One table offered 24 jams and another offered 6. The bigger display drew more people to stop and taste. But far more of the shoppers at the small display went on to buy a jar.
The finding became the symbol of the paradox of choice, a phrase popularized by the psychologist Barry Schwartz in his 2004 book of that name. It's a good story, and it's worth being honest about how far it goes. When researchers later pooled dozens of choice-overload experiments, the average effect came out close to zero. In some studies more options hurt, in some they helped, and in many nothing changed.
That doesn't kill the idea. It sharpens it. The research suggests choice overload isn't a law of nature. It shows up under particular conditions: when options are hard to compare, when you don't know what you want going in, when the stakes feel high, and when you're the kind of person who feels compelled to find the best.
That last condition is the interesting one.
Maximizers and satisficers
Schwartz and colleagues drew a distinction between two decision styles. A maximizer wants the best possible option and won't relax until they've checked everything. A satisficer (a word coined by the economist Herbert Simon in the 1950s, blending "satisfy" and "suffice") sets criteria that matter, then takes the first option that clears them.
In Schwartz's 2002 research using a maximization scale, people who scored high as maximizers tended to land better outcomes on paper. In one study of job seekers, for example, maximizers took jobs with higher starting salaries. But they reported less satisfaction with those jobs and more negative feelings through the search. They were also more prone to regret and to comparing themselves with others.
Put plainly, maximizers often get slightly more and enjoy it noticeably less.
The mechanism isn't mysterious. Two things happen at once.
Opportunity cost becomes vivid. Every option you pick means a dozen you didn't. With two choices, you lose one thing. With forty, you lose thirty-nine, and your mind can hold a faint picture of each. The thing you chose has to compete with a crowd of imagined alternatives, and imagined things have no flaws.
Expectations inflate. If there are forty restaurants, surely one of them is perfect. So an ordinary-great dinner becomes a disappointment, since it wasn't the perfect one. The more options exist, the more the blame for a mediocre result lands on you. You had every chance, and you still didn't find it.
This is the engine of regret. It's the sense that the better choice was out there and you failed to find it.
The hidden cost to curiosity
Here's the part that matters for anyone who wants an interesting life. Maximizing looks like thoroughness, but it often replaces exploration with comparison.
Curiosity moves toward something. You pick up the strange book and read it. You taste the dish you can't pronounce. Maximizing does the opposite: it hovers above everything, ranking. You can spend an hour reading reviews of three hiking trails and never walk a single one. Research becomes a way of feeling productive while avoiding the one thing that would teach you anything, which is the actual experience.
And experience is the only way to learn what you like. Preferences aren't sitting inside you waiting to be looked up. Often they're built by trying things. A maximizer who never commits never gathers the data.
Good enough is a skill, not a lowering of standards
It's tempting to hear "be a satisficer" as "settle." That misreads it. A satisficer still has standards. The difference is that the standards are set before the search and the search ends when they're met.
Simon's insight was about the limits of the mind: we have finite time and attention, so hunting for the true optimum is often irrational once you count the cost of the hunt. An hour spent finding the best sweater is an hour you didn't spend wearing a perfectly good one.
Not every decision deserves the same treatment. Choosing a spouse, a city, or a career is worth real deliberation. Choosing a Tuesday lunch is not. The skill is sorting decisions by how much they matter and how reversible they are, then matching the effort to that.
Your next moves
These are small, and each one can be done today.
- Sort one decision by reversibility. Pick something you've been dithering over. Ask: if this goes badly, can I undo it within a month, and does it cost me much? If yes to the first and no to the second, give yourself a hard ten-minute limit and choose.
- Write your criteria before you look. Before you open a single tab for your next purchase or booking, list three things it must have. Then take the first option that meets all three. Resist reopening the search once you've found it.
- Cap the candidates at three. For tonight's film, the weekend plan, or a gift, narrow to three options, then pick. Fewer options is often a gift to yourself, since you control the size of the menu.
- Delete one comparison habit. Unsubscribe from a "best deals" email, mute a shopping app, or close the review site you check after you've already bought something. Post-purchase checking is how regret gets manufactured.
- Do one thing with a good-enough pick. Take today's choice and follow through on it, whether that's watching the film to the end or walking the trail. Then notice one thing you liked about it. Satisfaction grows by attending to what you chose, rather than to what you passed on.
What you were really after
Behind most maximizing is a quiet fear: that the right choice exists, that a version of your life is waiting on the other side of it, and that you'll miss it by being careless. It's an understandable fear, and it's mostly a story. Few decisions have a single right answer. Most have several good ones, and the satisfaction comes from what you do after you pick.
The happiest chooser isn't the one who searched hardest. It's often the one who chose, committed, and then got curious about the thing in front of them.
That last step is where curiokit fits. It's built around small, low-stakes prompts that pull your attention toward something real, instead of leaving you hovering over a list of possibilities. If you find your evenings dissolving into scrolling and ranking, it might be a gentle way to practice picking one thing and leaning into it. Either way, tonight's rerun doesn't have to be the default. Choose something good enough, and look at it closely.